Marc Agnifilo is no stranger to high-stakes litigation. Known for his work as a seasoned criminal defense attorney, Agnifilo has carved out a formidable reputation for representing clients involved in some of the most complex and high-profile white-collar and criminal cases in the United States. His career spans decades, and his courtroom presence has often shifted the narrative in major legal battles, earning him a reputation as a fearless advocate and meticulous strategist.
Early Life and Education
Marc Agnifilo’s journey into the legal world began with a solid academic foundation. He earned his undergraduate degree at Columbia University before attending Brooklyn Law School. He later served as a prosecutor in the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office, where he honed his litigation skills and developed a deep understanding of prosecutorial strategy. This experience would later serve him well as he crossed over to criminal defense, where his insight into both sides of the courtroom became a distinct advantage.
Career Highlights
Agnifilo is best known as the former chief trial lawyer at Brafman & Associates, the law firm headed by the late Benjamin Brafman, another luminary in the world of criminal defense. At Brafman & Associates, Agnifilo handled a wide range of high-profile cases, often stepping into the national spotlight.
Among the most notable cases under his belt:
- Keith Raniere and the NXIVM Case: Perhaps the most high-profile and controversial case of his career, Agnifilo defended Keith Raniere, the founder of the NXIVM group, who was charged with a host of crimes including sex trafficking, forced labor, and racketeering. Although Raniere was ultimately convicted on all counts in 2019, Agnifilo’s defense drew attention for its sophistication and for grappling with a deluge of media attention, complex facts, and emotionally charged testimony. His performance in the courtroom was often lauded, even by critics of his client, for its professionalism under pressure.
- Martin Shkreli: In another nationally watched case, Agnifilo defended Martin Shkreli, the former pharmaceutical executive notorious for inflating drug prices. Though Shkreli was convicted on several counts of securities fraud in 2017, Agnifilo managed to get him acquitted of key charges that could have significantly increased his sentence. His handling of the case balanced legal rigor with the challenge of defending a client who had become a symbol of corporate greed.
- High-Profile Financial and Political Clients: Agnifilo has represented numerous clients in the financial industry, as well as political figures entangled in corruption charges. His courtroom demeanor and ability to simplify complex financial crimes for juries have made him a sought-after defense attorney in federal courtrooms across the country.
Legal Philosophy and Strategy
What sets Marc Agnifilo apart from many of his peers is his methodical approach to litigation. Known for exhaustive case preparation and compelling cross-examinations, he often employs a strategy that marries legal precision with narrative storytelling. His background as a former prosecutor adds to his ability to anticipate the other side’s moves—a skill that gives his clients a strategic edge.
Agnifilo also believes strongly in the presumption of innocence and the importance of a fair trial, even for clients who face overwhelming public scrutiny. This philosophy was particularly evident in the Raniere case, where despite significant public condemnation, Agnifilo maintained his client’s right to a rigorous and fair defense.
Public Perception and Controversy
Defending unpopular or controversial figures is not without its cost. Agnifilo has faced criticism for representing clients like Raniere and Shkreli, but he has consistently emphasized the importance of legal representation for all, regardless of public opinion. His work underscores a fundamental principle of American jurisprudence: that every defendant has the right to a competent defense.
In interviews, Agnifilo has stated that his role is not to endorse his clients’ behavior but to ensure the legal system functions properly. “What I do is represent people in the worst moments of their lives,” he once said. “The system only works if every person gets a fair shot.”
The Evolution of His Practice
In recent years, Marc Agnifilo co-founded the law firm Agnifilo Law Group with his wife, Teny Geragos, another high-profile defense attorney and the daughter of famed lawyer Mark Geragos. Together, they continue to represent clients in white-collar crime, federal litigation, and complex criminal matters.
Their firm emphasizes strategic defense grounded in meticulous research and preparation. They also offer consultation services in internal corporate investigations, a growing area as companies seek to proactively navigate regulatory and compliance risks.
Beyond the Courtroom
Outside the courtroom, Agnifilo has contributed to legal education through lectures and panel discussions. He is often invited to speak at legal seminars and conferences, where he discusses trial strategy, ethics, and the challenges of defending high-profile clients.
He is also a legal commentator and has appeared in media outlets to offer insights into ongoing trials and judicial matters. His commentary is valued for its clarity and depth, shaped by years of courtroom experience.
Conclusion
Marc Agnifilo represents the epitome of a modern defense lawyer: strategic, articulate, and unafraid to take on cases others might avoid. His willingness to defend controversial clients and his courtroom prowess have cemented his place as one of the leading criminal defense attorneys in the U.S.
In a legal landscape increasingly shaped by media scrutiny and public opinion, Agnifilo’s commitment to due process and fair representation remains a cornerstone of his practice. Whether facing down federal prosecutors, cross-examining key witnesses, or navigating the turbulent waters of public controversy, he has proven time and again that the art of criminal defense is as much about principle as it is about practice.
